The UAE has increased the minimum prison sentence that applies in certain intentional killing cases where the victim’s legal heirs waive their right to qisas.

Under the amended UAE Crimes and Penalties Law, an offender convicted of intentional killing can now face 15 to 20 years’ imprisonment where qisas is waived.

Previously, the applicable prison term in such circumstances could begin at seven years.

The amendment is important because it clarifies a principle that is sometimes misunderstood:

A victim’s family may waive its private right to qisas, but that does not extinguish the State’s separate interest in punishing an intentional killing.

The reform therefore strengthens the public-law consequences of the offence even where the victim’s family chooses forgiveness.

What Is Qisas?

Qisas is a form of retributive justice recognised within the UAE criminal-law framework in certain serious offences involving death or bodily harm.

In intentional killing cases, the victim’s legal heirs may hold a right to seek qisas, subject to the applicable legal requirements.

They may also choose to waive that right.

That waiver can be motivated by forgiveness, settlement, diya arrangements or other considerations recognised within the legal framework.

But the waiver does not mean that the underlying conduct ceases to be criminal.

That distinction is central to understanding the amendment.

What Has Changed?

The relevant amendment increases the custodial sentence where qisas is waived.

The new range is:

  • minimum: 15 years’ imprisonment
  • maximum: 20 years’ imprisonment

This is a substantial increase from the previous framework, where the minimum custodial sentence could be considerably lower.

The practical effect is that an offender cannot assume that waiver by the victim’s heirs will result in a comparatively limited prison term.

Even after qisas is waived, the court must still address the public dimension of the offence.

Why Family Forgiveness Does Not End the Case

Criminal law can involve more than one category of legal interest.

In a case of intentional killing, there may be:

  • a private right associated with the victim’s heirs; and
  • a public right connected to society, public order and punishment of serious crime.

The waiver of qisas affects the first.

It does not automatically eliminate the second.

This is why the case continues even after forgiveness.

The State retains an interest in punishing conduct that resulted in the intentional taking of a life.

The amended sentencing range makes that public interest significantly more visible.

Waiver Is Not an Acquittal

This point is especially important.

A waiver of qisas does not mean:

  • the accused is acquitted;
  • the conviction disappears;
  • criminal responsibility is erased;
  • or the court must release the offender.

Instead, the legal consequence is that the qisas element is removed, while a substantial custodial sentence can still be imposed.

The offender remains criminally responsible for the intentional killing.

The amendment reinforces that distinction.

Why the Minimum Sentence Has Been Increased

The policy rationale is clear.

The law is seeking to balance two interests.

The first is the recognised right of the victim’s heirs to waive qisas.

The second is the need to protect society and maintain strong deterrence for intentional killing.

If waiver automatically resulted in a low sentence, the public-law seriousness of the offence could be weakened.

By increasing the minimum term to 15 years, the law preserves the family’s right of forgiveness while ensuring that the State’s penal interest remains substantial.

Does the Court Still Have Discretion?

Yes, but within the statutory range.

Where the amended provision applies, the court can determine the appropriate sentence between 15 and 20 years.

That means sentencing can still take account of the circumstances of the case.

Relevant factors may include:

  • the nature of the offence;
  • surrounding circumstances;
  • the offender’s conduct;
  • aggravating or mitigating factors;
  • the impact of the crime;
  • and other matters permitted under the law.

But the court cannot go below the statutory minimum merely because qisas has been waived.

That is one of the key effects of the amendment.

Can Qisas Be Waived During Proceedings?

The timing of waiver can be legally important.

Depending on the procedural stage and the applicable legal rules, the victim’s heirs may be able to waive qisas during the proceedings or before execution of the sentence.

Where a legally effective waiver occurs, the case moves into the sentencing framework applicable after qisas has been relinquished.

This does not mean every case will follow the same factual path.

The legal validity and effect of any waiver must still be established properly.

What About Diya?

Qisas and diya are related concepts, but they should not be treated as identical.

Diya may arise as financial compensation in certain cases involving death or injury.

Whether diya applies, how it is calculated and how it interacts with other criminal consequences depends on the facts and applicable law.

The key point for present purposes is that even where the private rights of the heirs are resolved through waiver or compensation arrangements, the State may still impose imprisonment for the underlying intentional offence.

The Reform Strengthens the Public-Law Element

The amendment reflects a broader principle in serious criminal cases:

private forgiveness does not always remove public punishment.

This is especially important in intentional killing cases because the conduct affects more than the victim’s immediate family.

The State also has an interest in:

  • deterrence;
  • public safety;
  • accountability;
  • protection of life;
  • and maintaining confidence in the criminal justice system.

The new sentencing range makes that public dimension more explicit.

Why the Distinction Matters in Practice

The legal distinction between qisas and imprisonment can have major practical consequences for accused persons, victims’ families and lawyers.

A family considering waiver may believe that the decision will determine the entire criminal outcome.

It does not.

Likewise, an accused person may wrongly assume that securing a waiver will result in release or a dramatically reduced sentence.

The amended law makes clear that a long custodial term may still follow.

This is why legal advice is important before any waiver, settlement or related arrangement is finalised.

The Amendment Should Not Be Oversimplified

It would be inaccurate to describe the reform as simply saying:

“The family can forgive the offender, but the court still gives 15 years.”

The actual legal position is more nuanced.

The effect of waiver depends on:

  • the offence proved;
  • the applicable provision;
  • the procedural stage;
  • whether the waiver is legally valid;
  • and whether any other offences or aggravating circumstances are present.

The new 15-to-20-year range applies within a specific legal framework.

Each case must still be assessed individually.

Why This Is an Important Criminal-Law Reform

The amendment is significant because it clarifies the balance between two different dimensions of justice.

On one side is the personal right of the victim’s heirs.

On the other is the State’s responsibility to punish serious criminal conduct.

The law allows forgiveness to remain legally meaningful.

But it also makes clear that intentional killing continues to attract severe punishment even after qisas is waived.

That balance is central to the reform.

Conclusion

The UAE’s amendment to the Crimes and Penalties Law materially increases the custodial consequences of intentional killing where the victim’s heirs waive qisas.

The new sentencing range of 15 to 20 years’ imprisonment reinforces the principle that waiver affects the private right of retribution, not the State’s wider interest in criminal punishment.

The broader legal message is clear:

Forgiveness may remove qisas, but it does not erase criminal responsibility for intentional killing.

Al Kabban & Associates

For businesses seeking guidance, Al Kabban & Associates, with over 30 years of experience in UAE law and recognition by Legal 500, stands ready to help corporations build resilience against legal risks while ensuring compliance with local and international standards. For more information or to schedule a consultation, contact us at +971 4 453 9090 or visit www.alkabban.com. You can also follow us on social media for more updates on everything law related in the UAE: @Alkabban_Law

ALSO READ –


UAE Decriminalises Attempted Suicide: What the New Law Changes and What It Does Not

AIX Investment Group Payment Delays: What Affected Investors Should Consider Before Taking Legal Action

Who Owns a Viral AI Character? The UAE Copyright Question Behind Jean Phil, Abu Shalab and the New Generation of AI Influencers

Leave a Reply